
“As for The Numinous Way, I do now incline toward the view that this ethical Way of Life, which I have developed, is now independent of me, a complete philosophy of life, and can and should be judged as all such Ways, all such philosophies are judged, on their merits or their lack of them, independent of the life, and wanderings and mistakes, of those individuals who may have brought such Ways into being, or rather, who have presenced something of the numinous in the causal, just as the life of an artist, while it may or may not be interesting, does not or should not detract from or colour an artistic, aesthetic, judgement of his, or her, works of art.”
"The result of a four-decade long pathei mathos: the result of my many and diverse and practical (and, to many others, weird and strange) involvements (political, and otherwise), and my many and diverse and practical quests among the philosophies, Ways of Life, and religions, of the world. The Numinous Way is, in particular, the result of the often difficult process of acknowledging my many personal mistakes - many of which caused or contributed to suffering - and (hopefully) learning from these mistakes."
"There has been, for me, a profound change of emphasis, a following of the cosmic ethic of empathy to its logical and honourable conclusion, and thus a rejection of all unethical abstractions." (9)
"The faculty of empathy - and the conscious understanding of the nature of Reality - leads to a knowing, an understanding, of suffering. Part of suffering is that covering-up which occurs when a causal denoting is applied to living beings, and especially to human beings, which denoting implies a judgement (a pre-judgement) of such life according to some abstract construct or abstract value, so that the "worth" or "value" of a living-being is often incorrectly judged by such abstract constructs or abstract values."From a knowing and understanding of suffering, compassion arises, and:
"Empathy is thus, for The Numinous Way, the source of ethics, for what is good is considered to be that which manifests empathy and compassion and honour, and thus what alleviates, or what ceases to cause, suffering: for ourselves, for other human beings, and for the other life with which we share this planet. Hence, what is unethical, or wrong, is what causes or what contributes to or which continues such suffering."Furthermore, Myatt defines honor (or, more precisely, personal honor) as an ethical means to aid the cessation of suffering (13) and thus as "a practical manifestation of empathy: of how we can relate to other people, and other life, in an empathic and compassionate way".
" [The] uncovering of and knowing of the dependant nature of beings – of ourselves as one microcosmic connexion to Life and thus to other living beings, human, sentient, and otherwise – thus establishes a new theory of ethics, based on the personal knowing deriving from a personal πάθει μάθος and on the empathy of the immediacy-of-the-moment. " Some Notes Concerning Causality, Ethics, and Acausal Knowing
"For The Numinous Way, truth begins with a knowing of the reality of being and Being - part of which is a knowing of the dependant nature of living beings."
"There is... a fundamental and important distinction made, by The Numinous Way, between how we can, and should, perceive and understand the causal, phenomenal, physical, universe, and how we can, and should, perceive and understand living beings. The physical world can be perceived and understood as: (1) existing external to ourselves, with (2) our limited understanding of this 'external world' depending for the most part upon what we can see, hear or touch: on what we can observe or come to know via our senses; with (3) logical argument, or reason, being a most important means to knowledge and understanding of and about this 'external world', and a means whereby we can make reasonable assumptions about it, which assumptions can be refuted or affirmed via observation and experiment; and (4) with the physical Cosmos being, of itself, a reasoned order subject to laws which are themselves understandable by reason. In this perception and understanding of the causal, phenomenal, inanimate universe, concepts, denoting, ideas, forms, abstractions, and such like, are useful and often necessary." (15)
"The error of conventional philosophies - the fundamental philosophical error behind abstractionism - is to apply causal perception and a causal denoting to living being(s)." (18)
" The fundamental axiom (the foundation) of numinous philosophy – and thus of The Philosophy of The Numen – is that of empathy [ συν-πάθοs ]. That empathy is a natural faculty possessed by human beings, and presents to us, or can present to us, a type of knowing – a perception – quite distinct from that posited by both conventional philosophy and experimental science. That is, numinous philosophy adds the faculty of empathy to our physical senses; adds the perception of empathy to the perception of Phainómenon, and thus to the Aristotelian essentials of conventional philosophy and experimental science.
The perception which empathy provides is both of acausality and of the personal immediacy-of-the-causal-moment, and it is these which make numinous philosophy quite distinct from the causal reductionism, the impersonal abstractions, of both conventional philosophy and experimental science. For the essence of the faculty of empathy is a sympathy, συμπάθεια, with other living beings arising from a perception of the acausal reality underlying the causal division of beings, existents, into separate, causal-separated, objects and the subject-object relationship which is or has been assumed by means of the process of causal ideation to exist between such causally-separate beings. That is, and for instance, the implied or assumed causal separateness of living beings is appearance and not an expression of the true nature of Being and beings.
In essence, empathy presents the perception of the acausal-causal unity that forms the basis of Reality (of Being) – a perception which moves us, for instance, beyond the assumption of the isolated separateness of (and assumed importance of) our own individual selves, and which thus has important ethical, aesthetic, and social, implications."
"How can we develope this faculty [of empathy]? How can we reform ourselves and so evolve? The answer of The Numinous Way is that this is possible through compassion, empathy, gentleness, reason, and honour: through that gentle letting-be which is the real beginning of wisdom and a manifestation of our humanity. To presence, to be, what is good in the world - we need to change ourselves, through developing empathy and compassion, through letting-be, that is, ceasing to interfere, ceasing to view others (and "the world") through the immorality of abstractions, and ceasing to strive to change or get involved with what goes beyond the limits determined by personal honour." (19)
"Empathy, compassion, and a living by honour, are a means whereby we increase, or access for ourselves, acausal energy - where we presence such energy in the causal - and whereby we thus strengthen the matrix of Life, and, indeed, increase Life itself. Thus, when we live in such an ethical way we are not only aiding life here, now, in our world, in our lifetime, we are also aiding all future life, in the Cosmos, for the more acausal energy we presence, by our deeds, our living, the more will be available not only to other life, here - in our own small causal Time and causal Space - but also, on our mortal death, available to the Cosmos to bring-into-being more life. Thus will we aid - and indeed become part of - the very change, the very evolution of the life of the Cosmos itself."
" There is thus, or there can be, with empathy and its development, a translocation of ourselves, from what we regard as our self, toward and into other living beings, with this translocation being independent of causal, linear, Time. That is, the distinction we make - and which abstraction inclines us to make - between "them" and "us" no longer exists, for this distinction is fundamentally an illusion, a forgetting or a covering-up of, or a suppression and ignorance of, our own acausal nature......
Given this acausal translocation of ourselves, given this συν-πάθος, empathy moves us or inclines us toward a knowing of compassion and thus to the understanding that the cessation of suffering is the most practical manifestation, or presencing, of what is ethical. This is the desire, the intention, based on acausal knowing, not to inflict suffering upon or contribute toward the suffering of other living beings, human and otherwise."
" We are led to the assumption or the axiom of acausality because we possess the (currently underused and undeveloped) faculty of empathy [ συν-πάθοs ] - that is, the ability of sympathy, συμπάθεια, with other living beings. It is empathy which enables us to perceive beyond (to know beyond) the causal - and particularly and most importantly beyond the causal abstraction of the separation of beings: beyond the causal separateness, the self-contained individual being that causal apprehension presents to us, or rather has hitherto presented to us. That is, empathy reveals the knowing of ourselves as nexions - as a connexion to other life by virtue of the nature, the being, of life itself, and which life we, of course, as living beings, possess."
"The Cosmic Being..... is not perfect, nor omniscient, not God, not any human-manufactured abstraction. That is, it is instead a new kind of apprehension of Being: a Cosmic one, based upon empathy, and an apprehension which takes us far beyond conventional theology and ontology." (24)
"In essence, there was, for me, pathei mathos. Due to this pathei mathos, I have gone far beyond any and all politics, and beyond conventional religion and theology toward what I believe and feel is the essence of our humanity, manifest in empathy, compassion, personal love and personal honour. Hence, I cannot in truth be described by any political or by any religious label, or be fitted into any convenient category, just as no -ism or no -ology can correctly describe The Numinous Way itself, or even the essence of that Way. Therefore, I believe it is incorrect to judge me by my past associations, by my past involvements, by some of my former effusions, for all such things - all the many diverse such things - were peregrinations, part of sometimes painful often difficult decades-long process of learning and change, of personal development, of interior struggle and knowing, which has enabled me to understand my many errors, my multitude of mistakes, and - hopefully - learn from them." (26)In addition, he does not make any claims for his Numinous Way, other than it represents his own personal conclusions about life.
"The Numinous Way is but one answer to the questions about existence; it does not have some monopoly on truth, nor does it claim any prominence, accepting that all the diverse manifestations of the Numen, all the diverse answers, of the various numinous Ways and religions, have or may have their place, and all perhaps may serve the same ultimate purpose - that of bringing us closer to the ineffable beauty, the ineffable goodness, of life; that of transforming us, reminding us; that of giving us as individuals the chance to cease to cause suffering, to presence the good, to be part of the Numen itself." (27)
" We may define a new philosophy – the philosophy of πάθει μάθος – which is that of the way of a personal pathei-mathos combined with the way of experimental science, where we obtain knowledge about Reality, and may move toward certain truths about ourselves and existence, through direct practical, scientific observation of the phenomenal world, through the learning that derives from pathei-mathos, through the application of logic, and through an appreciation of a living tradition."
" Exactly how and where such new clans and tribes can be formed, is a matter for individuals to decide. A new clan really begins – comes-into-being – when a family decide to live in a certain, more numinous, manner, especially if this living is rural and isolates them from The State and its abstractions, and they do not have to depend on The State to provide them with all the necessities of living.
To be technical, I consider a clan to be an extended family, bound by ties of kinship and loyalty, and thus somewhat small, whereas a tribe can be said to be a small collection of clans living or dwelling together in the same locality or adjacent localities who initially are bound by ties of loyalty and often by a common need to cooperate (for reasons of food, or survival, or the sharing of natural resources, for instance) but who later on also become bound together by ties of kinship.
Thus, clans can evolve to become tribes which becomes a new folk. In the terms of old England, a clan is akin to a farm, home to many generations of the same family, who may expand to become a hamlet, while the tribe is akin to a small, rural, self-sufficient village of many families, where there is some specialization of work, for instance a farrier, a wheelwright, a miller." (29)
" The Numinous Way is one means whereby new numinous clans, and new numinous cultures, can be brought-into-being, and thus not only a means whereby the numinous can be presenced in and through us, as individuals, but also whereby we as individuals, and such new communities and new cultures as arise, can evolve in harmony with themselves, in harmony with Nature, and in harmony with the Cosmos....These new clans will be, according to Myatt:
[They] are thus nexions, regions where numinous law, based upon honour, can be established, to the benefit of the individuals of such new communities. A numinous clan ceases to be numinous - ceases to presence the numinous and thus ceases to be a living, changing, evolving, being - when individual empathy, individual knowing, individual character, and individual honour, cease to be the basis for inclusion, and there is, instead, a reliance and dependence upon causal abstractions." (30)
" ...small, rural, communities, which co-operate with, and which trade with, other local communities for their own mutual benefit. That is, a return to what is human; to the human-scale-of-things, and a moving-forward to a simple, ethical, letting-be based upon personal honour. This letting-be means that we concern ourselves with ourselves, and our immediate family and community - that we do not embark upon some abstract "crusade" in some foreign land where we desire to impose ourselves, our ways, upon others, and upon other cultures, and that we do not seek to expand at the expense of others, causing thus suffering to others." (28)
" The ideation – the causal abstraction – of race is a manifestation of ὕβρις. It conceals both the true nature of Being, and our true nature as human beings, which is that of Πόλεμος – and a revealing of which true nature is through the λόγος that is both causal and acausal knowing. A part of this acausal knowing is the dependant nature of (the acausal connexion between) living beings, and thus of the compassion that such a knowing logically leads us toward. This abstraction of race – like all causal ideations – distances us from the numinous, removes us from ἁρμονίη and thus καλλός and thus displaces us from that knowledge of Δίκα which is the basis for ἀρετή. In place of σωφρονεῖν there is instead the arrogance of a causal presumption.
As such, this abstraction of race is unethical, immoral, and thus dishonourable. "
I - Introduction to The Philosophy of The Numen; II - Concerning The Nature of Religion; III - Some Notes Concerning Causality, Ethics, and Acausal Knowing; IV - Acausality, Phainómenon, and The Appearance of Causality: V - An Introduction To The Ontology of Being; VI - On The Nature of Abstractions:; VII - Empathy and The Immoral Abstraction of Race; VIII - The Classical Foundations of The Numinous Way
In addition to citing these two works,
I have, on occasion, referred to some private correspondence between
Myatt and myself (both written,
and e-mail and dating from the past few years) where he elucidates
certain matters in response to a
particular question, or questions, of mine.
Myatt admits that, after his conversion to Islam in 1998, he did
continue to
develop and refine
this Numinous Way, spurred on by his experiences in the Muslim world,
and it was these experiences - and his study of Islam - which
significantly contributed to him expunging what he called the
"unethical and dishonourable abstractions of both race and the folk
from this philosophy." Private e-mail from
Myatt
to JRW, January 7, 2009
2) An Overview of The Numinous Way of Life
3) In Compassion, Empathy
and Honour: The Ethics of the
Numinous Way
4) Ontology, Ethics and The Numinous Way
6) Introduction, Empathy, Compassion, and Honour: The
Numinous Way of Life
7) A
Gnostic is someone who seeks gnosis - wisdom and
knowledge; someone
involved in a life-long search,a quest, for understanding, and who more
often
than not
views the world, or more especially ordinary routine life, as often
mundane and
often as a hindrance. In my view, this is a rather apt description of
Myatt.
8) Refer to Frequently Asked Questions About The Numinous Way
and An
Overview of The Numinous Way of Life
9) Introduction, Empathy, Compassion, and Honour: The
Numinous Way of Life
10) Refer to the section Ontology and The Numinous Way in
the chapter A Brief Analysis of The Immorality of Abstraction,
and also to Myatt's earlier essay Acausal
Science: Life and The Nature of the
Acausal which is referenced in that
chapter.
11) A Brief Analysis of The Immorality of Abstraction
12) A Brief Analysis of The Immorality of Abstraction
13) An Overview of The Numinous Way of Life
14) For more on abstractions, refer to Myatt's recent essay,
On
the
Nature of Abstractions (included in Corpus Numinosum).
Also, see his A Change of
Perspective,
dated 2454949
15) A Brief Analysis of The Immorality of Abstraction
16) Refer to An Overview of The Numinous Way of Life and Ontology,
Ethics
and
The
Numinous
Way and also Presencing The Numen In
The Moment
17) A Change of Perspective. Also, private e-mail from
Myatt
to JRW, April 23, 2009
18) A Brief Analysis of The Immorality of Abstraction
19) An Overview of The Numinous Way of Life
20) Acausal
Science: Life and The Nature of the
Acausal
21) Private e-mail from Myatt
to JRW, January 29, 2009
22) An Overview of The Numinous Way of Life. See also
The Numinous Way and Life Beyond Death
23) Ontology, Ethics and The Numinous Way. Also, private e-mail
from Myatt
to JRW, February 2, 2009
24) Ontology, Ethics and The Numinous Way
25) Private e-mail from Myatt
to JRW, February 2, 2009 and private letter from Myatt to JRW, which
he dated 23.iv.09 (CE)
26) Presencing The Numen In The Moment
27) The Empathic Essence
28) Refer to A Numinous Future - Beyond The Abstractions of The
State and The Nation
29) Some Questions Concerning The Folk, Race, and Empathy
30) The Clan, Culture, and The Numinous Way
31) Refer to An Overview of The Numinous Way of Life and also The
Principles
of
Numinous
Law. Also, and in respect of the difference between Buddhism
and Myatt's philosophy, refer to the article The Numinous Way and
Buddhism in his Three Essays Regarding The
Numinous Way
32) Among his dozens of recent autobiographical essays are the
following:
The Culture of ἀρετή - Essays in Praise of πάθει μάθοςI have collected some of his personal letters in a pdf file entitled The Private Letters of David Myatt, Part 1
So Many Tears
Love, Deities and God: Redemption and The Numinous Way
An Allegory of Pride and Presumption
One Simple Numinous Answer
The Empathic Essence